A page that ranks near the top when you search for megger pass values says this, word for word: “The IEEE 43 recommended minimum is 5 MΩ per kV of rated voltage plus 1 MΩ at 40 °C, so 4.4 MΩ for a 480 V motor.” Somebody is going to read that on a phone at the motor junction box, with the leads lifted and a number on the tester, and use 4.4 as the pass line. The sentence is wrong twice, and the second mistake can be caught with a pencil.
Run the formula the way it is written
480 V is 0.48 kV. Put that into the page’s own formula:
5 x 0.48 = 2.4
2.4 + 1 = 3.4
The formula returns 3.4 megohms, not 4.4. The answer printed in the sentence does not come out of the formula printed in the same sentence, which tells you nobody ever ran it. That is reason enough to stop trusting the figure before we even get to whether the formula is real.
The formula is not in IEEE 43
IEEE 43 has no 5 megohms per kV rule. Its table of recommended minimums, all corrected to 40°C, has three lines:
- kV + 1 megohms, for most windings made before about 1970, all field windings, and anything not covered by the other two lines
- 100 megohms, for most AC form wound windings made after about 1970
- 5 megohms, for most random wound stators and form wound coils rated under 1 kV
A 480 V motor with a random wound stator, which covers nearly every low voltage motor in the plant, lands on the last line. Its minimum is 5 megohms, flat, with no multiplying at all. The kV + 1 line is the one a lot of us learned first, and at 480 V it gives 1.48 megohms. Baldor puts it the practical way in its storage instructions: 5 megohms or kV + 1, whichever is greater. At 480 V that is 5. At 4160 V, kV + 1 comes to 5.16 and takes over. My guess is the page took the 5 from one line and the kV + 1 from another and bolted them together.
Why 4.4 does damage in both directions
The 4.4 line sits just under 5. On a modern 480 V motor it passes anything reading between 4.4 and 5 megohms, which is the motor that should be dried out or looked at before it ever sees voltage from a drive. On an older winding or a field winding, where the real minimum is 1.48, the same 4.4 line condemns a motor reading 2 or 3 megohms that the standard would pass. One wrong number, and which way it hurts you depends on what is bolted to the base.
5 megohms is a minimum, not a good motor
Even with the right number, the minimum is only where the decision starts. Before I call a motor good on the commissioning sheet, I want four things:
- The reading corrected to 40°C. Insulation resistance drops as the winding warms, and the old rule of thumb is that it halves for about every 10°C. A cold motor reading 12 megohms at 20°C corrects to about 3 at 40°C, and that is under the line. Newer insulation systems do not always follow that rule, so use the motor maker’s correction when you have it.
- All three phases to ground, recorded and compared. On a healthy motor they track each other. One phase well under the other two points at that winding or that conductor in the cable.
- A baseline you can trend. A motor that read in the thousands of megohms at startup and reads 20 three years later is telling you something, even though 20 passes. Baldor’s storage instructions treat a drop below half of the original reading as moisture in the windings.
- The leads lifted at the drive output before the test. Megger voltage through the drive will take out the output section. Leave the cable landed at the motor so the test covers the cable and the windings together.
Check the math before you trust the number
The habit that would have caught this is small. When a page hands you a formula and an answer, run the formula. It takes 10 seconds on the calculator in your pocket, and here it would have shown that nobody checked the figure. Then find the line in the table for the winding you actually have, correct the reading to 40°C, and compare it to that.
The megger test and the rest of the checks before first power are in the VFD Pre-Startup Checklist and the VFD Commissioning Guide. The full pre-energization sequence is in Before the First Fault, and if your crew is passing motors on a number they found on a search page, that is what the training is for.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the IEEE 43 minimum insulation resistance for a 480 V motor?
For a motor with a random wound stator, which is most 480 V motors, the recommended minimum is 5 megohms corrected to 40°C. For a winding made before about 1970 or a field winding, the minimum is kV + 1, which is 1.48 megohms at 480 V.
Is there an IEEE 43 formula of 5 megohms per kV plus 1?
No. IEEE 43 uses kV + 1 megohms for older windings and field windings, 100 megohms for most form wound AC windings made after about 1970, and a flat 5 megohms for random wound stators and form wound coils under 1 kV. And worked as written, 5 x 0.48 + 1 comes to 3.4, not the 4.4 that gets quoted with it.
Why correct the reading to 40°C?
Because insulation resistance changes a lot with winding temperature, and the IEEE 43 minimums are stated at 40°C. A cold motor reads high. As a rule of thumb the reading halves for about every 10°C rise, so a motor reading 12 megohms at 20°C is closer to 3 at 40°C. Use the motor maker's correction when you have it.
What polarization index should I look for?
IEEE 43 calls for a polarization index of at least 2.0 on Class B insulation and above, and 1.5 on Class A. When the 1 minute reading is above 5,000 megohms the index is not needed. On small random wound motors it often adds little, and the corrected reading, the phase comparison, and the trend tell you more.
Is a reading just above 5 megohms good enough to start on a drive?
It meets the minimum for a random wound motor, and that is all it does. Compare all three phases, compare against the last reading on that motor, and find out why it is that low before the drive puts its full DC bus on the windings every pulse.
Online start-up courses, filmed on real drives
One drive per course, filmed uncut with a clock on screen from first power to a saved backup. The install course is free, and the ABB ACS380 and ACS580 start-up course is open now.