A centrifugal pump is about as easy a load as a drive gets, which is why its setup gets rushed. The drive will run a pump at 22 Hz all summer without complaint while the pump makes no flow, heats the water in the casing and cooks its seals. On a well, the same mistake takes out the motor’s thrust bearing 300 feet down, where the repair bill starts with a pump truck.
This note is the setup, in order, for the 3 kinds of pump jobs that come across the counter: surface centrifugal pumps, positive displacement pumps and submersible well pumps.
First, which kind of pump is it
The drive needs to know what kind of load it is turning, and pumps come in 2 kinds that behave nothing alike.
| Pump | Load type | What it means for the drive |
|---|---|---|
| Centrifugal (end suction, split case, vertical turbine, submersible) | Variable torque | Torque falls with speed squared, power with speed cubed. Big energy savings at reduced speed. |
| Positive displacement (progressive cavity, gear, lobe, diaphragm, plunger) | Constant torque | Torque stays the same at every speed. Needs full torque at start and at low speed. |
A positive displacement pump can need heavy torque at start and all the way through its speed range, so size the drive on its constant torque rating and check the starting current and torque it can actually deliver. A centrifugal pump needs much less torque at reduced speed and usually qualifies for the drive’s variable torque rating. On most drives the variable torque rating allows about 110 percent current for 60 seconds and the constant torque rating about 150 to 160 percent, and a load that needs the higher number but gets the lower one is the classic drive that will not start.
Surface centrifugal pumps
- Size the drive on current, not horsepower. Use the motor’s nameplate FLA at the installed voltage, and size up for long cable, high ambient and altitude. The VFD sizing guide works through the factors.
- Set the load type to variable torque, or the pump and fan macro if the drive has one.
- Set the ramps. Long enough to keep the pipe from hammering on start and stop. Seconds, not tenths.
- Find the real minimum speed. A pump’s head falls with the square of speed. Against a high static head there is a speed below which the pump stops moving water out of the pipe at all and runs at no flow. Staying above zero flow is not enough, though. The pump maker publishes a minimum continuous flow, and below it the pump can run rough or heat up even while some water is moving. Use the pump curve and the system curve to find the speed that keeps the pump above that minimum, then confirm it at startup with a pressure gauge on the discharge and a way to read flow. A minimum picked from habit, 20 Hz because the last job used 20 Hz, is how pumps cook.
- Set the maximum speed from the pump and the process, not the motor. The top speed comes from the pump curve and what the process actually needs, before the motor’s limits ever come into it. Running past base speed is rarely worth anything and is often a step backward: power climbs with the cube of speed, the motor runs into overload, and the pump moves out on its curve toward runout, where it can cavitate. Set the maximum at the speed that covers the highest real demand. On most jobs that is 60 Hz or less.
- Set up the PID loop if it is a pressure or level job. Transducer scaled in the drive to match its range, setpoint in engineering units, and a sleep function so the drive stops the pump at low demand instead of running it at minimum speed doing nothing. Pump drives like the ABB ACQ580 also carry an underload curve for dry pump detection, worth turning on where a suction can run dry.
- Watch the motor’s cooling. A TEFC motor on a centrifugal pump is usually fine at low speed, because the load falls faster than the cooling. Long hours at very low speed on a large motor is still worth a look at the motor temperature.
- Walk the speed range on larger pumps. Run slowly from minimum to maximum speed and listen and feel for vibration. If one band shakes the pump, the base or the piping, set the drive’s skip frequencies to step over it. Yaskawa calls them jump frequencies and ABB calls them critical speeds.
The energy side of this job is real and it is load dependent. At 80 percent speed a centrifugal pump needs about half the power. The note on what a VFD actually saves is the honest version of that math, including what static head does to it.
Positive displacement pumps
- Set the load type to constant torque, or use the heavy duty rating if the drive offers 2.
- Size for starting torque. A progressive cavity pump with a tight stator can take well over running torque to break away. Sensorless vector control, or a torque boost setting in V/Hz mode, helps the drive make that torque at low speed.
- Watch low speed cooling. Torque does not fall with speed on these, so a TEFC motor running a metering pump at 10 Hz is carrying full load with a fraction of its cooling air. A common guideline is to avoid sustained operation below about 20 Hz without separate cooling, and some go to 30 Hz on motors of 50 HP and up, but the motor maker’s speed range rating and thermal limits are the real answer. Where the lowest speed calls for it, use a blower cooled motor or a larger frame.
- Protect against a closed discharge. A positive displacement pump against a closed valve will build pressure until something gives. The drive’s current limit is not a relief valve. The system needs one.
Submersible well pumps
A submersible is a centrifugal pump with a motor that lives underwater and depends on the water flowing past it for cooling and on its own speed for bearing lubrication. Every rule below comes from that. These are Franklin Electric’s rules for its three-phase encapsulated submersibles. Other makers publish their own, compared below, and the manual for the motor in the well wins.
- Use a three-phase motor. Franklin’s three-phase motors can run on a drive inside its guidelines. Its single-phase motors can only be used with Franklin’s own constant pressure controller, so a general purpose drive on a single-phase well motor is off the table.
- Size the drive on the motor’s nameplate maximum amps, not horsepower. The drive’s continuous rated current has to be at least the nameplate maximum or the warranty is void.
- Set the frequency limits to 30 Hz minimum and 60 Hz maximum. 30 Hz is the minimum speed that keeps the thrust bearing lubricated. Above 60 Hz needs special system design, and 60 Hz is a ceiling, not a target: the pump curve and the well’s real demand set the top speed, the same as on a surface pump.
- Set the acceleration so the motor reaches 30 Hz within 1 second. This is the rule that surprises people who came from surface pumps. A slow ramp through low speed runs the thrust bearing without its film.
- Set the stop. The best stop is power off and a natural coast. A controlled stop from 30 Hz to 0 Hz is allowed as long as it takes no more than 1 second.
- Confirm cooling flow past the motor. At least 0.25 feet per second for 4 inch motors and 0.5 feet per second for 6 and 8 inch motors, at the lowest speed the drive will run. Franklin’s 4 inch motors of 2 HP and smaller only need flow greater than zero, so check the cooling table for the motor you have. If the well is large in diameter or the water enters above the motor, it needs a flow sleeve.
- Set the motor overload. Trip at 115 percent of the system’s typical operating current, at least as fast as a NEMA Class 10 curve.
- Set the underload. Franklin’s rule is to pick the underload trip point so the minimum cooling flow is always met. Record the normal running current, then set the underload trip, its delay and the restart limit so a dry well or a pump that has lost its prime shuts down instead of running. 30 Hz keeps the thrust bearing lubricated. It says nothing about whether water is moving past the motor.
- Put the output filter in. For Franklin’s 380 to 575 V motors: no filter under 50 feet of motor cable, a dV/dt filter from 50 to 800 feet with the carrier at 2 to 2.5 kHz, and a sine wave filter beyond 800 feet with the carrier above 4 kHz. Those distances are Franklin’s for its own motors, not general filter rules, and the filter maker’s carrier range for the filter you buy has the final say on the carrier setting. Franklin says more than 99 percent of drives applied to well motors meet the requirements to need one, and a line side filter does not replace it.
- Keep starts well under 200 in 24 hours. 200 is the most Franklin allows on a drive, not a target, and fewer starts are easier on the motor. A pressure tank sized for the system and a sleep function with a sensible wake band take care of most of it. If the drive log shows the pump short cycling, fix the tank or the wake band.
- Use the drive’s submersible pump setting if it has one. If not, the centrifugal pump or fan setting is the right starting point.
How other motor makers compare
Grundfos, Xylem’s CentriPro line, Pentair’s Pentek motors and Wilo all agree with Franklin on the part that matters most: get through low speed fast and do not run below a minimum near 30 Hz. After that the details split, which is why the manual for the motor in the well has the last word.
| Maker | Minimum speed | Time to reach it | Stop | Cooling flow past the motor | Output filter |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Franklin | 30 Hz | 1 second | Coast, or 30 to 0 Hz in 1 second or less | 0.25 ft/s on 4 inch, 0.5 ft/s on 6 and 8 inch | dV/dt from 50 to 800 feet, sine wave past 800 |
| CentriPro | 30 Hz | 1 second | 4 seconds from minimum to shutoff | 0.5 ft/s | A filter or line conditioning device on the motor leads |
| Grundfos | 30 Hz | Enough flow at the lowest speed | Sine wave filter, LC type acceptable and RLC preferred | ||
| Pentair (Pentek) | 30 Hz on 6 to 8 inch, 42 Hz on 10 inch | 1 second to 30 Hz | 4 seconds from minimum to shutoff | 0.5 to 1.64 ft/s depending on size | A reactor or filter on 400 V class motors to hold the peak under 1,000 V |
| Wilo | 25 to 30 Hz on 2 pole motors | 1 or 2 seconds by motor, never more than 2 | Filter required on PE2 windings, and PE windings not allowed on a drive at all |
The top end is capped too. Franklin needs special design above 60 Hz, Grundfos says not to run past nominal frequency, and Pentair limits its motors to full load speed. Pentair and Wilo both want the carrier low: Pentair says to use the lowest carrier that does the job and not go above 4 kHz without asking the factory, and Wilo starts commissioning at 4 kHz.
2 differences are worth calling out. The stop rule runs opposite directions: Franklin wants the stop fast or a coast, while CentriPro and Pentair write in a 4 second ramp down. And the filter rules do not match each other or the distances used for ordinary motors. Grundfos also warns that an MS motor with a temperature transmitter loses the transmitter when it runs on a drive, because its fuse melts.
Filters: pump makers versus the induction motor rule
For a standard induction motor, the cable distance rule stands: a load reactor under about 250 feet, a dV/dt filter to about 500 feet, a judgment call from 500 to 1,000 feet on motor rating and risk, and a sine wave filter past 1,000 feet, always checked against the drive maker’s cable length table. That covers the surface pumps in this note, and reflected wave and long motor leads explains why cable length matters so much.
Pump companies often write their own filter rules, and the makers of integrated designs most of all, where the motor and pump are built and warranted as one unit. Their rules usually start shorter and go stricter. Franklin calls for a dV/dt filter from 50 feet and a sine wave filter past 800. Grundfos treats a sine wave filter, RLC type preferred, as standard on its three-phase motors on a drive. Wilo will not put a drive on its standard PE winding at all and requires a filter on the PE2 winding, which it limits to 1,000 V peak and 500 V per microsecond at the motor. On those motors, the pump maker’s rule replaces the distance bands, because it is the pump maker’s warranty on the line.
2 things about well drives catch people. Franklin’s submersibles are not declared inverter duty under NEMA MG1, yet they are warranted on drives as long as these rules are followed, so the inverter duty question is answered by the motor maker’s manual, not the nameplate. And the filter rule starts at 50 feet, much shorter than the distances used for an ordinary induction motor.
Single-phase services
A lot of wells sit on single-phase power, and that does not rule out a drive. Use a drive rated for single-phase input and three-phase output, or a three-phase drive that its maker approves for single-phase input with a published derating. Size it on that single-phase rating and the motor’s nameplate maximum amps, and run it inside the motor maker’s rules.
Before you leave the site
Record the minimum speed you set and why, the ramp times, the filter part number, the motor’s nameplate maximum amps and the running current at the normal setpoint. The next person to touch the drive will want to know that the 30 Hz minimum and the 1 second ramp were deliberate. A label inside the drive door does that job: “Min 30 Hz and 1 second accel per Franklin thrust bearing rule. Underload trip set for minimum cooling flow. dV/dt filter installed, carrier 2.5 kHz.” The VFD Commissioning Guide and the free commissioning checklist give you a place to put it.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can you put a VFD on a well pump?
Yes, on a three-phase submersible motor, inside the motor maker's rules. Franklin Electric's three-phase encapsulated motors can run on a drive as long as the drive is sized on the motor's nameplate maximum amps, the motor never runs below 30 Hz or above 60 Hz, it reaches 30 Hz within 1 second of starting, and an output filter is used when the cable calls for one. Single-phase Franklin motors can only be used with Franklin's own constant pressure controller.
What is the minimum speed for a submersible pump on a VFD?
For Franklin Electric submersibles, 30 Hz. That is the speed the motor needs to keep its thrust bearing lubricated, and the motor has to reach or pass 30 Hz within 1 second of being energized. 30 Hz protects the bearing but does not prove the motor is getting enough cooling flow, so set underload protection as well. Grundfos, CentriPro and Pentair's smaller Pentek motors use the same 30 Hz minimum, Pentair's 10 inch motors use 42 Hz, and Wilo allows 25 to 30 Hz on 2 pole motors, so read the manual for the motor in the well.
Does a well pump VFD need an output filter?
Usually. For 380 to 575 V Franklin motors, no filter is needed under 50 feet of cable, a dV/dt filter from 50 to 800 feet, and a sine wave filter beyond 800 feet. Franklin says more than 99 percent of drives applied to water well submersibles meet the requirements to need an output filter, and that a line side filter does not replace it. Grundfos goes further and calls for a sine wave filter on its three-phase motors on a drive.
Should a pump VFD be set to variable torque?
For a centrifugal pump, yes. Its torque falls with the square of speed, which is what the variable torque setting assumes. A positive displacement pump is a constant torque load and should be sized and set up as one, or the drive may not have the starting torque it needs.
How do I set the minimum speed on a centrifugal pump VFD?
Use the pump curve and the system curve to find the speed that still makes enough head to keep the pump above its maker's minimum continuous flow, then confirm it with pressure and flow readings at startup. A pump's head falls with the square of speed, so below a certain speed it stops moving water against the static head and runs at no flow, heating the water and the pump.
Online start-up courses, filmed on real drives
One drive per course, filmed uncut with a clock on screen from first power to a saved backup. The install course is free, and the ABB ACS380 and ACS580 start-up course is open now.