The motor on a 60 HP pump starts across the line, the lights dip in the building, and the pipe bangs every time it starts and stops. Someone asks for a VFD. Sometimes that is the right answer, and sometimes the pump runs at full speed all day and the problem was only ever the start, in which case a soft starter fixes it for less money and with none of the side effects a drive brings.
The question that decides it comes first, and everything else is detail.
The one question: does it need speed control after the start?
If the process needs the motor to run at different speeds, to hold a pressure, match a line rate or save energy at part load, it needs a VFD. A soft starter cannot change running speed. Once its ramp is done, it puts the motor on the line, usually through a bypass contactor, and the motor runs at nameplate speed.
If the motor runs at full speed whenever it runs, and the only problem is the inrush, the torque shock on the coupling and belts, or the hammer in the pipe, a soft starter is in the running and usually wins on cost.
What each one does at start
A soft starter uses SCRs in each phase to chop the voltage and ramp it from a starting level up to full voltage over the ramp time. Lower voltage means lower current, and it also means much lower torque, because an induction motor’s torque falls with roughly the square of the voltage. Current falls in proportion to voltage. Torque falls faster. Better units go past a simple voltage ramp: they hold a current limit during the start, and some run a torque control mode that shapes the start and stop around the motor’s torque instead of its voltage.
A VFD lowers frequency and voltage together, which keeps the motor’s flux at its rated level. The motor makes rated torque at low speed from around rated current, and a drive can deliver starting torque up to its overload rating, commonly about 150 percent for 1 minute on a heavy duty rating. Check the data sheet for the drive in front of you. How much of that torque you actually get at standstill depends on the control mode, the motor and the drive’s current rating, so sensorless vector does better than plain V/Hz on a hard start.
The starting torque math
Take a motor that draws 6 times FLA across the line and makes 150 percent of full load torque at locked rotor. That is a typical shape for a general purpose motor. Set a soft starter to limit the start to 3 times FLA.
- 3 times FLA out of 6 times FLA means the starter is holding the motor at about half voltage.
- Torque at half voltage is about a quarter of what it would be at full voltage.
- A quarter of 150 percent is about 37 percent of full load torque at the moment of start.
A centrifugal pump or fan needs very little torque to start, so 37 percent is plenty and the ramp brings it up to speed. A loaded conveyor, a mixer full of product or a positive displacement pump against pressure can need 100 percent or more to break away. On those, the soft starter either sits there humming or has to be set so high that the start is barely soft at all. A drive starts them at close to rated current.
This is a simplified locked rotor comparison, not a prediction of the whole start. The current limit is a ceiling, and voltage, slip, current and torque all change as the motor comes up to speed. Get the actual locked rotor current and torque from the motor data sheet, and look at the load’s torque and inertia, before you run this on a real job. The shape is what matters, and it does not change: a soft starter trades torque for current at a bad rate.
Time is the other price. A 191 amp motor started across the line pulls about 1,200 amps for roughly a second. On a soft starter set for a typical pump start it pulls about 700 amps, but for 8 seconds instead of 1. The line sees less, and the motor and starter carry it longer.
The decision, load by load
| Load | Usually the better fit | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Centrifugal pump or fan, full speed when running | Soft starter | Low starting torque, no speed control needed, lower cost |
| Centrifugal pump or fan with variable demand | VFD | Speed control and energy savings, power falls with roughly the cube of speed |
| Pressure or level control | VFD for modulating control, soft starter for on and off control | A PID loop needs a drive. A pump cycled by level or pressure switches at full speed does not |
| Loaded conveyor, mixer, crusher | VFD for heavy breakaway or controlled acceleration, soft starter if the torque works out | High breakaway torque is hard to get at low current, but a soft starter can work when the numbers allow |
| Positive displacement pump | VFD for variable flow or hard starts, soft starter if the starting torque allows | Constant torque from start to full speed |
| High inertia fan, long acceleration | Either, after checking start time, starts per hour, motor heating and the starter’s thermal rating | Long starts heat the SCRs and the motor |
| Compressor that runs loaded or unloaded at full speed | Soft starter, if it starts unloaded | Low starting torque when unloaded |
| Single speed submersible well pump | Soft starter set to the motor maker’s ramp limits, or a VFD if pressure control is wanted | Franklin asks for full voltage within 3 seconds on a soft start |
The conveyor row is not a rule against soft starters on conveyors. One 200 HP, 1,800 RPM stacker conveyor was started across the line in about 1 second, putting about 900 foot pounds on the motor shaft and roughly 54,000 pounds on the conveyor. It broke 4 or 5 belts a year at about 6 hours a repair. With a soft starter it went 20 months without a break. A set of cooling towers with 14 motors of 200 HP each was throwing couplings and torque tubes on 1 second across the line starts, and soft starters stopped it. Both were loads where the shock was the problem and the starting torque was there.
If it is a soft starter, set it up right
Soft starters are some of the most misapplied equipment I see, and the usual mistake is setting one up as if it were a drive, with a long, slow ramp meant to ease the motor up to speed. That is never what a soft starter is for. Its job is the torsion: taking the hammer blow out of the coupling, the belts, the gearbox and the pipe in the first second of a start. The motor still has to get to full speed quickly.
- Size it on current and duty. More than 10 starts an hour, go up one size. Above 40 degrees C, derate about 1 percent per degree.
- Check the connection setting. Make sure the starter is set for inline wiring, not inside delta, unless it really is wired inside the delta. Inline and inside delta carry different current ratings.
- Use the bypass. Once the motor is up to speed the bypass contactor carries it, which keeps the SCRs cool and takes them off the line where surges and dips can reach them.
- Set the current limit from the load, not from habit. Too low and the motor stalls or the start drags on and overheats things. Too high and the start is barely soft at all.
- Keep the ramp short. Acceleration should generally finish in under 10 seconds, and it always has to finish inside what the motor overload class allows. A Class 10 overload trips at 6 times rated current within 10 seconds, a Class 20 within 20 and a Class 30 within 30, so a long ramp at high current is a nuisance trip or a cooked motor waiting to happen. If the load cannot reach speed inside that window at a current the line can stand, it is a drive job, not a soft starter job.
- On a pump, use the torque control stop if the starter has one. A plain voltage ramp stop on a pump often does nothing for a couple of seconds and then lets go all at once, and that drop is the water hammer. Torque control brings the speed down in a smooth line instead.
- Confirm motor overload protection, built in or a separate relay.
What else changes with the choice
A drive brings things with it that a soft starter does not.
- Cable and motor. A drive’s fast output edges need VFD cable, an inverter rated motor on longer runs, and sometimes an output reactor or filter. A bypassed soft starter puts a sine wave on the motor and none of that applies. See VFD cable and reflected wave and long motor leads.
- Bearings. Drives put common mode voltage on the motor shaft. Soft starters running in bypass do not. See a grounding ring cannot outrun a bad install.
- Harmonics. A drive’s rectifier draws harmonic current the whole time it runs. A soft starter’s SCRs make harmonic current only while they are switching during the ramp, and none once the bypass closes.
- Heat in the panel. A drive dissipates a few percent of its power for as long as it runs. A bypassed soft starter dissipates almost nothing.
- Motor protection and diagnostics. Most drives and many soft starters have electronic motor overload built in, but not all. ABB’s entry level PSR soft starter needs a separate overload relay, while its PSE and PSTX carry their own. Check the unit you are buying. A drive gives you more running data, because it is controlling the motor the whole time.
Old motors and long runs
A soft starter is often the right call when the motor is old, its insulation class is unknown and the cable run is long. Putting a drive on that motor means asking a winding that was built for 60 Hz to take reflected wave peaks it was never tested for, and the fix is a filter or a new motor. A soft starter in bypass gives that motor the same sine wave it has always had. The note on inverter duty motors covers what a drive asks of the winding.
When it is close
When the load could go either way, run the energy numbers before deciding on first cost. A centrifugal pump that spends many hours at reduced flow can be a strong drive candidate, especially if the flow is controlled with a throttling valve today. Work the savings from the real pump and system curves, the operating hours and the power cost. A system that is mostly static head saves much less than the cube law suggests, and a pump that runs flat out or not at all saves nothing. The note on what a VFD actually saves is the honest way to do that math, and VFD for pumps and well pumps covers setting a drive up on a pump.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the difference between a soft starter and a VFD?
A soft starter ramps the voltage up during the start and then, usually through a bypass contactor, lets the motor run at full speed on the line. A VFD changes the frequency and voltage the whole time the motor runs, so it controls speed as well as the start and stop. If the process needs speed control, it needs a drive.
Is a soft starter cheaper than a VFD?
Usually, and it is smaller, runs cooler once bypassed and does not need VFD cable, output filters or an inverter duty motor. The savings disappear if the load would have paid back a drive in energy, which centrifugal pumps and fans that run below full flow often do.
Why won't my conveyor start on a soft starter?
Because a soft starter cuts torque faster than it cuts current. Motor torque falls with roughly the square of the applied voltage, so limiting the start to half voltage leaves about a quarter of the motor's locked rotor torque. A loaded conveyor can need more than that to break away. A VFD can make full rated torque at start from around rated current.
Can a soft starter stop a pump without water hammer?
It depends on how it stops. A plain voltage ramp stop often does little for the first seconds and then loses torque all at once, and the pump stops hard anyway. A soft starter with a torque control pump stop brings the speed down smoothly and is built for this job. A VFD controls the speed directly. Neither one fixes a check valve or piping problem, so look at the hydraulics too.
Should I use a soft starter or VFD on a well pump?
If the well runs at one speed and only needs a gentler start, a soft starter is often the simpler answer. Franklin Electric asks for full voltage within 3 seconds on its three-phase submersibles, and within 2 seconds when a SubMonitor is used. If the system needs constant pressure from a variable demand, a VFD set up to the motor maker's drive rules is the better fit.
Online start-up courses, filmed on real drives
One drive per course, filmed uncut with a clock on screen from first power to a saved backup. The install course is free, and the ABB ACS380 and ACS580 start-up course is open now.