Field note

dV/dt Filter vs Load Reactor: Which One the Motor Run Needs

A load reactor and a dV/dt filter get ordered as if they were the same part in 2 price ranges, and on a lot of jobs one gets ordered because the last job had one. They do the same kind of work at different strengths. The question that picks between them is how much voltage the motor at the end of the cable can take, and how long that cable is.

This note is the decision in order, with the distance bands drive people use, the exceptions that break them, and how to measure whether you chose right.

What problem the output device solves

A drive switches its DC bus, about 650 to 680 VDC on a 480 V system depending on load, onto the motor cable in a fraction of a microsecond. The cable behaves like a transmission line, the pulse reflects off the motor’s higher impedance, and the 2 add. On short runs the reflection has less room to build, though with today’s fast switching edges it can still show up on surprisingly short cable. At 200 to 300 feet, 1,200 to 1,600 V at the motor terminals is common on standard drives, and on longer runs the peak heads toward twice the bus. That peak and the steepness of the edge are what wear out the first turns of a motor winding. The note on reflected wave and long motor leads is the full mechanism.

Every output device on this page attacks that peak, that edge, or both.

The 3 options

Load reactor (output reactor). An inductor in series with each motor lead, mounted at the drive. It slows the voltage edge and lowers the reflected peak. It reduces the spike without removing it: on a 460 V system with 200 feet of cable, a spike around 1,200 V typically comes down to roughly 800 to 900 V with a reactor. That is not guaranteed. On a run well past the critical length, a reactor can leave the peak nearly where it was, so its benefit depends on the reactor, the drive’s edge, the cable and the motor, and the drive maker’s approved reactor list is the place to pick one. It is the cheapest option, and it also helps small drives with long cables by cutting the cable charging current that trips them on overcurrent.

dV/dt filter. A purpose built output filter that limits how fast the voltage rises at the motor and cuts the reflected peak further than a reactor. Designs vary: some are an inductor with capacitors and damping resistors, others a tuned inductor and resistor network. What sets a dV/dt filter apart from a plain reactor is that it is engineered and rated for a specific rise time and peak voltage over a defined range. Its makers publish a carrier frequency range it is designed for, because its effectiveness depends on the switching frequency, so the drive’s carrier has to be set inside that range.

Sine wave filter. A larger inductor and capacitor filter that turns the PWM pulses into something close to a sine wave before the cable. The motor sees nearly what it would see on the line between phases, so reflected wave, insulation stress and PWM motor noise mostly go away. Common mode voltage is a separate problem. A conventional sine wave filter smooths the phase to phase voltage and does not necessarily remove the common mode voltage that drives bearing currents. Some sine wave filters add common mode filtering, MTE sells one of each, and a job that needs both protections has to buy for both. A sine wave filter costs the most, it drops some voltage that has to be allowed for at top speed, and it has to be matched to the drive’s current, output frequency and carrier. Some come with limits on the drive’s control mode and a minimum carrier setting, so read the filter maker’s setup notes before commissioning.

The distance bands

These are conservative field practice for inverter rated motors on 480 V systems, not physical limits. The real critical length depends on the drive’s rise time, the cable and the motor’s surge withstand.

Total motor lead lengthUsual choice
Under 250 feetLoad reactor, or nothing if the drive maker’s table allows the run bare
250 to 500 feetdV/dt filter
500 to 1,000 feetJudgment call on motor rating, drive and how much risk the job can carry
Over 1,000 feetSine wave filter

Inside the dV/dt band, roughly 250 to 700 feet, the dV/dt filter is also the better choice on lifecycle cost. Every filter burns some power for every hour it runs. A sine wave filter buys a little more reliability than a dV/dt filter at a higher continuous energy cost, and the filter makers’ published watt losses are the numbers to compare for a given job. The extra cost is worth it on a long run to a critical motor or a retrofit where the old motor cannot be replaced, and usually not worth it on a run where the motor is getting swapped for an inverter rated one at the next outage.

What the filter makers rate their parts for

The filter makers rate their products for longer runs than these bands. MTE sizes its load reactors for leads up to about 300 feet, its dV Sentry dV/dt filter to about 1,000 feet, and its sine wave filters to about 15,000 feet. TCI promotes its V1k dV/dt filter to 1,000 feet on standard drive jobs, and up to 3,000 feet on specific applications with the factory involved. TCI says the V1k holds the peak to about 1,000 V on a typical 480 V system and around 1,200 V on a 600 V system, and it wants the drive carrier at 8 kHz or less.

Those ratings and the bands are not in conflict. The bands are a conservative starting point that works without knowing the filter part number. Once a specific filter is chosen, its maker’s rating, the motor’s withstand at its voltage and the drive maker’s table decide the job. The 600 V number is worth noticing: about 1,200 V at the motor is inside the Part 31 envelope for a 575 V inverter duty motor, but it is over the 1,000 V that Part 30 allows a standard motor, so a standard 575 V motor on a long run usually ends up on a sine wave filter.

The drive makers build the same thinking into their manuals. ABB’s own tables call for a du/dt filter on its standard insulation motors on supplies above 500 V. Yaskawa’s GA500 manual says to confirm the motor insulation or use an inverter duty motor when the input is 440 V or higher or the run is longer than 100 m (328 feet), and it lowers the allowed carrier frequency as the cable gets longer.

The decision, in order

  1. Read the motor’s insulation rating. Inverter rated or not, and the peak voltage and rise time the maker will stand behind at that voltage. The note on inverter duty motors covers what those numbers mean.
  2. Measure the total lead length. If one drive feeds more than one motor, add every lead together for the drive’s limits, the way Yaskawa’s carrier table counts the total wiring to all connected motors. Judge each motor’s insulation on its own run.
  3. Read the drive maker’s cable length table at the motor’s rating. This is the step most often skipped, and it is the one that decides the job. The same drive can be allowed 25 feet of cable on a 1,000 V winding and 1,200 feet on a 1,488 V winding. Where the 1600 volt number comes from shows a real table.
  4. Pick the device. If the table allows the run with nothing on the output, you are done. If not, use the distance bands above and the device the drive maker lists for that drive.
  5. Set the carrier frequency inside the range the filter maker publishes. A dV/dt or sine wave filter run at the wrong carrier can overheat or resonate.
  6. Measure the result. A qualified technician measures the phase to phase waveform at the motor terminals, not at the drive, using a properly rated scope and a high voltage differential probe. Make the test connections with the equipment de-energized and locked out, then run it under the electrical safety rules that apply. Record the peak voltage, the rise time, the drive frequency and the carrier, and compare them to the motor maker’s insulation limits and the filter’s specification. An ordinary meter cannot see these edges. This is the step that proves the choice instead of assuming it, for the waveform under those conditions.

Where the bands do not apply

Submersible well motors and other integrated pump designs. Pump companies whose motor and pump are built and warranted as one unit write their own filter rules, they usually start much shorter, and on those motors they replace the bands above. Grundfos treats a sine wave filter as standard on its three-phase motors on a drive. For 380 to 575 V Franklin Electric submersibles, no filter is needed under 50 feet of motor cable, a dV/dt filter is recommended from 50 to 800 feet with the carrier at 2 to 2.5 kHz, and a sine wave filter beyond 800 feet with the carrier above 4 kHz. The rest of the well setup is in VFD for pumps and well pumps.

Standard motors that are not inverter rated. The Part 30 envelope is 1,000 V peak with rise times of 2 microseconds or slower. A reflected wave on a few hundred feet of cable is past that, so a standard motor that has to stay on a long run needs either a sine wave filter or a dV/dt filter specified and measured to keep it inside that envelope.

Newer drives. Drives with better IGBT gate control can cut dV/dt by about half compared to older ones, which stretches every band, though the edge leaving the drive is not the same as the edge that arrives at the motor. SiC drives switch faster and can shrink them. Read the table for the drive in front of you.

The part people mix up

A line reactor on the input and a load reactor on the output are the same kind of part doing different jobs. The input reactor, usually 3 to 5 percent impedance, cuts harmonics, balances the line current, eases the stress on the bus capacitors and takes the edge off transients. It does nothing for the motor. The output reactor protects the motor and cable and does nothing for the supply. A drive on a long run often needs both. The note on IEEE 519 compliance covers the input side. And do not pull a spare line reactor off the shelf and put it on the output. A reactor on the drive output has to be designed for the PWM waveform it will see there.

The cable on the output matters as much as the device. A filter in front of an unshielded cable still leaves the common mode current hunting for a way home, which is covered in VFD cable and in the VFD Installation Guide.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the difference between a load reactor and a dV/dt filter?

A load reactor, also called an output reactor, is an inductor between the drive and the motor cable. It slows the voltage edges and usually cuts the reflected wave peak, but does not remove it, and on a very long run it may not cut it much. A dV/dt filter is engineered and rated for a specific rise time and peak voltage, so it slows the edges more and holds the peak lower. As a field rule, reactors cover runs to about 250 feet and dV/dt filters to about 500 feet.

When do I need a sine wave filter on a VFD?

On very long runs, roughly 1,000 feet and beyond, on standard motors that are not inverter rated, and where motor noise has to be low. A sine wave filter turns the PWM pulses into a near sine wave before the cable, which takes care of reflected wave and insulation stress. A conventional sine wave filter does not necessarily remove common mode voltage, so bearing protection may still be needed unless the filter includes common mode filtering. It costs the most, drops some voltage and has to be matched to the drive's current and carrier frequency.

Is a line reactor the same as a load reactor?

It is the same kind of part in a different place. A line reactor goes on the drive input and protects the drive from the supply and the supply from the drive's harmonics. A load reactor goes on the drive output and protects the motor and cable. One does not do the other's job, and a reactor used on the output has to be designed for the drive's PWM output.

Do I need an output filter for a well pump VFD?

Usually, and at much shorter distances than surface motors. For 380 to 575 V Franklin Electric submersibles, a dV/dt filter is recommended from 50 to 800 feet of motor cable and a sine wave filter beyond 800 feet.

How do I know if the motor needs an output filter?

Read the motor's insulation rating and the total motor lead length, then read the drive maker's cable length table at that rating. If the run is longer than the table allows without a filter, it needs one. To be sure, measure the peak voltage at the motor terminals with a scope and a high voltage differential probe, and compare it to what the motor is rated for.

Online start-up courses, filmed on real drives

One drive per course, filmed uncut with a clock on screen from first power to a saved backup. The install course is free, and the ABB ACS380 and ACS580 start-up course is open now.

See the online courses

Wayward Leaders® is a veteran-owned VFD training practice. We teach maintenance teams and plant electricians to install, commission, and troubleshoot variable frequency drives correctly.

Every class ends with a scored competency assessment. The plant gets a way to prove what each technician can do, not a roster of who sat in the room.

The instruction is field-trained. It is drawn from nearly 8,000 VFD, power, and motor documents and from more than 750 commissioned drives captured through personal field experience and data collection. Carl Lee Tolbert, PhD, CMRP, and ATD Master Trainer™, leads it. He has delivered more than 5,000 hours of VFD instruction across 30 years and trained 8,000 industrial professionals, from International Paper to the U.S. Navy.

The premise is simple: VFDs do not fail. Installations fail them. The curriculum is built backward from that.

Installation, commissioning, troubleshooting, and fault diagnosis guides are published openly at waywardleaders.com.